Fly Selection in the Berry Islands

Mar 26

Fly selection is one of those things that we CAN control. In a sport where elements are constantly changing it’s nice to focus on the details that we can have some command over. In comes fly selection. There’s a lot to think about here but we can break it down relatively simply. We’ve got a great selection of flies at Soul Fly Lodge so please feel free to lean on our expertise. Stellar FL keys permit guide Rob Kramarz has developed an excellent selection for Soul Fly Lodge. With each order with Rob we tweak and get closer to perfection. Rob has personally fished and visited Soul Fly and has a vested interest in our permit pursuits. We’re thankful for his expertise. Commercially tied winners are also available for the thrifty angler.

Understand the Prey: Naturally, I’ll always select an imitation that I know lives on the flat that I’ll be fishing. Ask your guide, he or she will provide valuable information.
Fly Color: In general, I aim to match the bottom color of the flat that I’m fishing. If I specifically know that the forage I’m matching differs in color then I will match those nuances.
Fly Weight: This one is very important and it also entangles with the topics of leading your target and presentation. Bahamas flies (from lightest to heaviest) come: unweighted which is less common, assorted sizes of beadchain eyes, and assorted sizes of solid metal eyes. A fly with a light beadchain eye might be perfect to throw at that tailing bonefish in 6” of water. The fly will land lightly and reduce the chance of spooking that fish. BUT keep in mind that you can still present to that same tailing bonefish with a heavier fly by leading the fish further. Heavier flies can be very handy in deeper water where you need to get the fly to the bottom quicker. Fish, in general, are less spooky in deeper water so you can afford to lead that fish with a heavier fly that gets to the zone quickly.
Fly Size: #4 to #8 is a perfect size range for bonefish. If the fish are being finicky, go smaller. Adjust and adapt. #4 sized permit flies should be adequate in most situations.

Just remember, these are all simply suggestions. There are very few hard and fast rules on the flats. These are wild fish with dynamic personalities. Keep it loose and trust your instincts. Berry Island bonefish and permit have been fooled by hundreds of different patterns so just member that it’s all about a stealthy approach and a cunning presentation. See below for some specific flies I like: